FA Cup Without VAR: A Football Controversy Explained

FA Cup Without VAR: Was It Better Without Technology? ⚽🔥

Football fans are divided. 🤯 The FA Cup fourth round sparked heated debates—not over VAR decisions, but over its absence! With video assistant referee (VAR) technology missing, controversial moments went unchecked.

Some loved the raw, old-school football experience. Others? Furious over costly referee mistakes. So, was the FA Cup better without VAR? Let’s break it down.

🚨 What Happened in the FA Cup?

In the FA Cup 4th round, VAR was not used due to FA rules. This meant:

⚽ No video replays for referee decisions

🚩 No offside checks

✋ No handball reviews

Several controversial goals and decisions went unchecked:

🔴 Brighton vs. Chelsea – Handball before Brighton’s winner ❌

🔵 Man United vs. Leicester – Maguire scored an offside goal 🚩

⚪ Leyton Orient vs. Man City – A possible foul before Orient’s stunning goal 🤔

Without VAR, emotions ran high. But was it good for football?

📊 Fan Reactions: Do Fans Want VAR or Not?

Football fans had mixed opinions on VAR’s absence.

📢 Some fans loved it:

🗣️ “Football was better before VAR. Celebrations feel real again!”

🗣️ “Referees make mistakes, but that’s the drama of football.”

😡 Others hated it:

🗣️ “We got knocked out because of a missed handball. Unfair!”

🗣️ “If VAR is used in some rounds, it should be used in all!”

📊 Was the FA Cup better without VAR?

✅ Yes – More emotions, less delays

❌ No – Too many referee mistake

🔍 Why Was VAR Not Used?

The FA decided VAR would only be used from the 5th round onwards. Why?

🛑 Not all stadiums have VAR technology

💰 VAR costs money – only Premier League clubs use it regularly

⚖️ FA wanted fairness – either all clubs get VAR, or none

But there’s a strange rule: Goal-line technology WAS used, but VAR wasn’t. This led to even more confusion.

⚽ The Big Controversies – Should VAR Have Been Used?

Let’s analyze the biggest VAR debates from the FA Cup:

1️⃣ Brighton 2-1 Chelsea – Handball or Not?

🔍 Incident: Tariq Lamptey’s shot bounced off his arm before Mitoma scored.

❌ VAR Verdict: Goal should have been disallowed.

📢 Chelsea fans: “With VAR, we’d still be in the FA Cup!”

2️⃣ Man United 2-1 Leicester – Offside Winner

🔍 Incident: Harry Maguire was offside before scoring the last-minute winner.

❌ VAR Verdict: Goal should NOT have stood.

📢 Leicester fans: “VAR would have saved us!”

3️⃣ Leyton Orient 1-2 Man City – Foul Before Goal?

🔍 Incident: Leyton Orient’s first goal came after a possible foul on City’s Nico González.

✅ VAR Verdict: Unclear – Would have needed a replay.

📢 City fans: “We deserved a fair review!”

🧐 Should the FA Cup Always Use VAR?

There are strong arguments on both sides:

👍 PRO-VAR Argument:

✅ Prevents big mistakes (offside goals, handballs)

✅ Makes football fairer

✅ Used in top leagues, so FA Cup should have it too

👎 Anti-VAR Argument:

❌ Slows the game down

❌ Kills the emotion of goal celebrations

❌ Some VAR calls are still wrong

What do you think? 🤔 Comment below! 👇

🔮 The Future of VAR – What’s Next?

The FA Cup quarter-finals WILL have VAR. This means:

🔹 Handball checks are back

🔹 Offside goals can be reviewed

🔹 Referees have video help

Is this fair? Should VAR be in every round? Vote in our poll! ⬇️

📊 Should VAR be used in every FA Cup match?

✅ Yes – All rounds need fairness

❌ No – Let’s keep football raw and exciting

📢 Final Thoughts: Football Needs Consistency

The FA Cup debate proves one thing: Football needs clear rules. Fans want:

✅ Consistency – Use VAR in ALL rounds, or NONE

✅ Faster VAR decisions – No long delays

✅ More fan engagement – Polls, discussions, and real-time updates

The debate isn’t over. But one thing is clear: Football’s technology debate is here to stay.

🔗 Related Content You’ll Love!

📌 [Best FA Cup Moments of All Time] 🏆

📌 [VAR Controversies That Changed Football] 🚀

📌 [Biggest Referee Mistakes in Football History] 😱

👋 Over to you! Do you think VAR makes football better or worse? Comment below! ⚽👇

📢 Follow us on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram for more football debates!