Everton 1-1 Arsenal: Ndiaye’s Controversial Penalty Halts Gunners’ Title Charge | Arteta Fury & Liverpool Boost
Iliman Ndiaye’s controversial penalty earns Everton a 1-1 draw vs Arsenal, crushing the Gunners’ title hopes!
4/5/20253 min read


🔥⚽️ Everton 1-1 Arsenal: Ndiaye’s Controversial Penalty Derails Gunners’ Title Hopes | Premier League Drama Unpacked! 🏆
In a match that epitomized the chaos and controversy of the Premier League, **Everton** clawed back to secure a **1-1 draw** against **Arsenal** at Goodison Park, dealing a crushing blow to the Gunners’ faint title aspirations. A contentious penalty decision, a goalkeeping masterclass, and a tactical chess match defined this clash, leaving Liverpool 11 points clear at the summit. Here’s your **deep dive** into the drama, stats, and fallout from a game that reshaped the title race! 🎭
🌪️ Match Overview: Grit Meets Controversy at Goodison**
Arsenal arrived at Goodison Park needing a win to keep their slim title hopes alive, but Everton’s resilience and a **VAR-awarded penalty** ensured the points were shared. Leandro Trossard’s first-half opener was canceled out by **Iliman Ndiaye’s spot-kick**, sparking fury from Mikel Arteta and relief for David Moyes’ battling Toffees.
**Final Score:**
- **Everton 1** (Ndiaye 49’ pen)
- **Arsenal 1** (Trossard 35’)
⚡ Key Moments: From Trossard’s Brilliance to Penalty Pandemonium**
1. Trossard’s Clinical Opener (35’)**
Arsenal struck first after a **Raheem Sterling-led counterattack**. The winger surged 40 yards before slotting the ball to Trossard, who drilled a low shot through Jake O’Brien’s legs and past a unsighted Jordan Pickford.
2. Penalty Controversy (49’)**
Everton’s equalizer came via a **hotly debated penalty**. Myles Lewis-Skelly tangled with Jack Harrison on the edge of the box, with replays showing minimal contact. Despite Arsenal’s protests, VAR upheld the decision, and Ndiaye coolly sent David Raya the wrong way.
3. Pickford’s Heroics**
The England keeper made **8 saves**, including a stunning reaction stop to deny Trossard in the 77th minute. His performance earned him widespread praise, with Arteta lamenting, “Their keeper was phenomenal”.
4. Arteta’s Rotations Backfire**
With an eye on Tuesday’s Champions League clash against Real Madrid, Arteta benched **Bukayo Saka, Martin Ødegaard, and Gabriel Martinelli**. The trio’s second-half introduction sparked urgency, but Arsenal lacked cohesion.
5. Emotional Tribute to Kevin Campbell**
Both sets of fans united in the ninth minute to applaud former Arsenal and Everton striker **Kevin Campbell**, who passed away in 2024. His family watched on as the stadium paid homage to his legacy.
📊 By the Numbers: Stats That Tell the Story**
- **Possession**: Arsenal 62% vs Everton 38%
- **Shots on Target**: Arsenal 9️⃣ vs Everton 2️⃣
- **Expected Goals (xG)**: Arsenal 1.8 vs Everton 0.6
- **Saves**: Pickford 8️⃣ vs Raya 1️⃣
- **Fouls**: Everton 13 (4 yellows) vs Arsenal 10 (0 cards)
🌟 Standout Performers**
⭐ Jordan Pickford (Everton) – 9/10**
The Everton keeper’s reflexes kept his team in the game, particularly his double save against Trossard and Martinelli.
⭐ Leandro Trossard (Arsenal) – 8/10**
A goal, 3 key passes, and relentless movement—Trossard was Arsenal’s brightest spark.
⭐ Iliman Ndiaye (Everton) – 7.5/10**
Cool under pressure, the Senegalese forward converted the penalty and troubled Arsenal’s defense with his dribbling.
📉 Title Race Implications**
- **Liverpool’s Title March**: The Reds now need **11 points from 8 games** to clinch their 20th league title.
- **Arsenal’s Reality Check**: The draw leaves them 11 points adrift, effectively ending their challenge. Arteta admitted, “The game is up”.
- **Everton’s Survival Boost**: The point lifts them to 14th, 7 points clear of relegation.
🗣️ Manager Reactions**
- **Mikel Arteta (Arsenal)**: “The penalty decision changed everything. I’ve watched it 15 times—it’s never a penalty. We deserved more”.
- **David Moyes (Everton)**: “We showed character. Against the top teams, you need luck, and we got it today”.
🔍 Tactical Breakdown: Why Arsenal Faltered**
1. **Midfield Mismanagement**: Without Ødegaard’s creativity, Arsenal’s buildup was sluggish. Jorginho and Rice were overrun by Everton’s press.
2. **Defensive Lapses**: Lewis-Skelly’s inexperience showed in the penalty incident, while Saliba struggled against Beto’s physicality.
3. **Everton’s Low Block**: The Toffees’ 5-4-1 formation congested the midfield, forcing Arsenal into hopeful crosses (27 attempted, 5 successful).
💥 The VAR Debate: Was It a Penalty?**
The decision divided pundits:
- **Gary Neville**: “Soft, but contact started outside the box. VAR got it wrong”.
- **David Moyes**: “I haven’t watched it, but I’ll take it!”.
🔮 What’s Next?**
- **Arsenal**: Shift focus to the **Champions League quarterfinal vs Real Madrid** on Tuesday.
- **Everton**: Face Nottingham Forest (A), Man City (H), and Chelsea (A) in a brutal run-in.
- **Liverpool**: Can seal the title by May 11 if results go their way.
✨ Final Take: A Season-Defining Stalemate**
For Arsenal, this draw symbolizes a season of *almosts*—brilliant in flashes but lacking the ruthlessness to topple Liverpool. Everton, meanwhile, showcased the grit that’s kept them afloat in a turbulent campaign. As the title race fizzles, the Premier League’s drama remains unmatched! 🔥
🔑 Key Takeaways**
1. **Title Race Over**: Liverpool’s lead is insurmountable.
2. **Pickford’s Redemption**: Proved why he’s England’s No. 1.
3. **Arteta’s Gamble**: Rotation for Real Madrid backfired.
4. **VAR Controversy**: Yet another talking point in a heated season.
**📌 SEO-Optimized Tags**:
#Everton #Arsenal #PremierLeague #Ndiaye #Pickford #Arteta #TitleRace #VAR #Football